This reaction type propeller turbine is an evolution of the francis turbine. B francis an american engineer who in beginning designed inward. Kaplan turbine has lesser friction loss and higher efficiency. The comparisons of the calculated results with the verified standard 4k. This operates in an entirely closed conduit to tailrace. Kaplan turbine adjustable blades bulbtype bulge in pipe. May 06, 2017 in this video lecture i have discussed about the difference between francis turbine vs kaplan turbine from the unit turbine of fluid mechanics or fluid machineryhydraulics or hydraulics machinery. Turbine is a device that extracts energy from a fluid. Kaplan turbine it is an axial flow reaction turbine. Francis and kaplan turbines notes for civil engineering.
Pelton turbine propellers francis and kaplan banki. This method of detailed design, is followed by a complete tutorial for the 3d modeling of the turbine. It is the vertical difference between headrace and tailrace. Kaplan turbines can operate under a wide range of head conditions, but francis turbine requires relatively higher head conditions. The cfd approach for prediction of efficiency of a 3 mw capacity horizontal axis francis turbine is presented. Open channel flow specific energy and rapid transitions hydraulic jumps slowly varying flow open channel control structures 3.
Kaplan turbine has very small number of blades 3 to 8 adjustment of runner vanes. Francis turbine is a mixed hydraulic turbine the inlet velocity has radial and tangential. About kaplan turbines the kaplan turbine is one of the most commonly used turbines types in hydropower facilities around the globe. Its invention allowed efficient power production in lowhead applications which was not possible with francis turbines.
Kaplan turbine is more compact in crosssection and has lower rotational speed to that of francis turbine. The kaplan turbine was an evolution of the francis turbine. The inlet guidevanes can be opened and closed to regulate the amount of flow that can pass through the turbine. Pumps, turbines and pipe networks moment of momentum revisited types of pumps and turbines and uses pumppipe systems, networks 2. Its similar to the propeller turbine, except that its blades are adjustable. Enter your email to be alerted to the latest posts on the reliability matters blog. General differences between francis and kaplan turbines. Francis turbines are probably used most extensively because of their wider range of suitable heads, characteristically from three to 600 metres. Pelton wheel easiest to understand invented in california late 1800s. Difference between kaplan and francis turbine compare. On this channel you can get education and knowledge for general issues and topics.
Micro hydropower plants mhps play an important role in the rural electrification of nepal. Unlike impulse turbine, the water completely fills the casing of a reaction turbine. Francis turbine converts energy at high pressure heads which are not easily available and. Oct 30, 2016 on this channel you can get education and knowledge for general issues and topics. Further a manual separated operation of each guide vane servomotor will be. An example is the kaplan turbine, invented by victor kaplan 18761934 and first put into service in 1912, with movable blades that rotate, or feather, to handle different conditions, the key to making an efficient propeller turbine. The savonius wind turbine is an aerodynamically drag based, selfstarting turbine with low cut in speed but their inefficiency curtails them to fewer applications, whereas, darrieus wind turbines. Pdf effects of load variation on a kaplan turbine runner. The following documents are referred to in the text in such a way that some or all of. In fact, the guide vanes of a francis turbine are usually movable for the same purpose. The kaplan turbine gives higher efficiency about 90%. The rotation speed rpm is higher than that of the francis turbine.
The process of the kaplan turbine design is used as an example in this paper. Introduction a water turbine is a device for converting water fluid power into shaft mechanical power. The specific speed of pelton turbine ranges between 830, francis turbines have specific speed between 50250, specific speed of kaplan lies between 250850. Common types francis turbine centrifugal pump francis turbine cutaway three gorges francis turbine. The difference in the operating head can be extra simply controlled in francis turbine than in the pelton wheel turbine.
The head h is difference between headwater and tailwater. Less friction losses as compare to francis turbine. Mar 24, 2014 difference between frances turbine and kaplan turbine type of turbine. Difference between pelton, francis and kaplan turbines.
It is an axialflow turbine, which means that the flow direction does not change as it crosses the rotor. This video gives a short introduction to the kaplan, francis and pelton type hydroelectric turbines. Both serve almost the same purpose only names along with slight operating ways and their time of arrival is different. Hydraulic turbines and hydroelectric power plants 1. A simulation of the kaplan turbine is in general more time consuming than a simulation of the francis turbine. Kaplan turbine is a propeller type water turbine along with the adjustable blades. Kaplan, francis and pelton hydroelectric turbines youtube. The efficiency of a turbine is highly influenced by its runner wheel and this work aims to study the design of a kaplan turbine runner wheel.
The control equipment and the outlet transformers are located in the generator forebay. Abstract the aim for turbine design is to increase the efficiency and avoid cavitation and fractures during operation. It was developed in 19 by austrian professor viktor kaplan, who combined automatically adjusted propeller blades with automatically adjusted wicket gates to achieve efficiency over a wide range of flow and water level the kaplan turbine was an evolution of the francis turbine. Mar 14, 20 unlike impulse turbine, the water completely fills the casing of a reaction turbine. This method of detailed design, is followed by a complete tutorial for the 3d modeling of the turbine blades, and.
Francis turbines are the most common water turbine in use today. General arrangement of kaplan 1 introduction this short note indicates how a preliminary design of an axail. Note that this analysis is approximate and is useful for a. Very simple kaplan turbine design grant ingram 30th january 2007 nomenclature b blade height g gravitational acceleration h head k loss coe. Tailrace which is a channel carrying water away from the turbine after the water has worked on the turbines. Efficiency of francis turbine is less as compare to kaplan turbine. The impulse types where there is no pressure difference between the inlet. Therefore, the overall efficiency curve is an envelope of partial efficiency curves, which are determined at a fixed angle of runner blades. M is the mass flow rate in kgs and h is the pressure head difference over the turbine in. Difference between francis and kaplan turbine pdf 23. Difference between frances turbine and kaplan turbine. Kaplan turbine disposition of shaft is only in vertical direction number of vanes france turbine has very large number of blades 16 to 24 kaplan turbine has very small number of blades 3 to 8 adjustment of runner vanes.
The kaplan turbine runner has 38 blades while francis turbine runner has 1525 blades in general. Impulse turbines are typically used with highhead systems and use nozzles to produce the highvelocity jets. In this video lecture i have discussed about the difference between francis turbine vs kaplan turbine from the unit turbine of fluid mechanics or fluid machineryhydraulics or hydraulics machinery. Va tech turbine manufacturer was contracted to create a prototypescale computer model of a lower granite turbine unit. Austrian engineer viktor kaplan 18761934 invented this turbine. What is the difference between a pelton wheel and the. Sectional and top view of a francis reaction turbine 18. It was named after james bicheno francis 18151892, the american engineer who invented the apparatus in 1849. At large guide vane openings there is often a clearance between. On the other hand francis and kaplan turbines are reacti. At the highhead range, the flow rate and the output must be large.
May 06, 2017 hi all in this video lecture i have discussed about the difference between francis turbine vs kaplan turbine from the unit turbine of fluid mechanics or fluid machineryhydraulics or hydraulics machinery. Hydraulic turbines difference between impulse and reaction hydraulic turbines. The water surface in the tailrace is also referred to as tailrace. The head ranges from 1070 metres and the output ranges from 5 to 200 mw. This type of turbine is located in the old lowhead installations less than10 m where they are generally in water chamber, ie without scrollcase. Very simple kaplan turbine design durham university. Design, performance and maintenance of francis turbines. The mechanical efficiency of the pelton wheel turbine decreases faster than the francis turbine. Kaplan turbine has a higher efficiency than francis turbine. What is the difference between a pelton wheel and the francis. Subsequent developments were made on francis, pelton and kaplan turbines. Verification of model calculations for the kaplan turbine design. Kaplan reaction turbines are axial flow turbines in which the flow is parallel to the axis of the shaft. Pdf design and analysis of a kaplan turbine runner wheel.
Jun 08, 2018 francis turbine is radial flow turbine but in case of modern francis turbine water enters radially and leaves the turbine axially which is called as mixed flow turbine. Verification of model calculations for the kaplan turbine. A brief discussion on a the design philosophy during the last 60 years with will be presented. Hydraulic turbines fundamental operating parameters classification impulse turbines pelton turbines reaction turbines radial flow. The wheel is immersed and operates both the water velocity kinetic energy, that a pressure difference. A kaplan turbine is a water turbine that was developed by austrian professor viktor kaplan in 19 and francis turbine was developed by james. The rated head and discharge for the turbine were 48 m and 7. Introduction to surface water hydrology hydrologic cycle. The comparisons of the calculated results with the verified standard 4k69 kaplan turbine confirm the compliance of. Efficiency of kaplan turbine is higher than francis turbine.
Hence, these are the parameter changes that has to be incorporated in converting a francis turbine to kaplan turbine. Pumps, turbines and pipe networks moment of momentum revisited. Improvement of efficiency prediction for a kaplan turbine. What is the differences between pelton turbine and kaplan. The computational model consists of spiral casing, 18 numbers of stay vanes and guide vanes, runner having numbers of blades and a draft tube. You will find the heliciel site, a method of minihydropower plant design, complete, allowing the design and performance estimation and dimensional parameters of the propeller or kaplan turbine, from guide vanes to draft tube. The kaplan turbine is a propellertype water turbine which has adjustable blades. Hydraulic turbineshydraulic turbines raven mechanical. In order to better understand the correlation between the hydraulic shapes of the stay vanes and wicket gates and both environmental and turbine performance, a computational fluid dynamics cfd model was created. Kaplan turbine is employed, where a large quantity of water is available. Difference between kaplan and francis turbine compare the. General arrangements for pelton, francis, kaplan and kaplan bulb turbine power.
Explain the significance of specific speed to turbine selection. Mainly it is designed for low head water applications. Difference between frances turbine and kaplan turbine free download as pdf file. At the lowhead end, propeller turbines are usually more. Like kaplan turbine, the francis is a reaction machine. Difference between frances turbine and kaplan turbine type of turbine.
Selection of optimal number of francis runner blades for a. Evolution from francis turbine to kaplan turbine wikipedia. The difference between the sum of the static and potential heads at entrance to the runner and at the exit from the runner is 62 m. The main difference between kaplan and francis turbines is the design of the runner which is, respectively, axial and radial. Nov 05, 2010 hydraulic turbines difference between impulse and reaction hydraulic turbines. Water enters the runner without shocks with a flow velocity of 9. Solve numerical problems for a pelton wheels and a francis turbine. Francis turbine variation in the operating head can be more simply controlled. A kaplan turbine is basically a propeller with adjustable blades inside a tube.
The francis turbine converts potential energy into mechanical energy. Introduction to turbine machinery univerza v ljubljani. Kaplan turbine is smaller and compact compared to francis turbine. It consists of spiral casing, guide mechanism and draft tube of kaplan turbine runner are similar to those of francis turbine. Hi all in this video lecture i have discussed about the difference between francis turbine vs kaplan turbine from the unit turbine of fluid mechanics or fluid machineryhydraulics or hydraulics machinery. Difference between frances turbine and kaplan turbine scribd.
The inward flow reaction turbine having radial discharge at outlet is known as francis turbine, after the name of j. There are two main types of reaction turbine francis and kaplan turbines. Pumps, turbines, and pipe networks, part 2 ch 11 young. Following are the differences between pelton wheel, francis and kaplan turbine. Classification of hydraulic turbines rmd 2501 hydraulic turbines are generally classified as impulseturbineimpulse turbine peltonturgoturbinepelton, turgo turbine reaction turbine francis, kaplan and propeller turbine based on flow direction, they are further classified as.
Difference between kaplan and francis turbine kaplan and francis are two types of turbines which were developed by two different engineers. First, a theoretical design was performed for determining the main characteristics where it showed an efficiency of 94%. The performance of hydraulic turbines is strongly influenced by the characteristics. Design and analysis of a kaplan turbine runner wheel. Differences between francis and kaplan turbines mech4study. Reaction turbine generally produces more power than an impulse turbine. Specific speed of a turbine is defined as the speed of a geometrically similar turbine which produces a unit power when working under a unit head. Cfd, francis turbine, sediment erosion, efficiency, performance, optimum number of blades.
270 1177 50 577 191 1571 17 749 84 1539 1078 102 552 1536 492 641 497 1606 100 1438 1041 1472 929 967 723 413 515 267 879 274 422 595 771 780 564